Forgotten lore

I’ve got a quick story today, one that has been floating around the aether for a while. It originally appeared in Scrye magazine, and as such was at risk of being lost for ever now that we rarely get news from any place where people don’t flame you for playing the “wrong” cards in your deck.

Steve Guitar of New Brunswick, Canada, was surprised
when a customer at his shop showed him a Goblin Mob
theme deck from Scourge. The problem with the cards?
The card backs were from the Wizards of the Coast’s
Harry Potter CCG.

“I called Wizards of the Coast, and they told me I couldn’t
be right,” said Guitar, owner of B&T Cards in Bathurst, New
Brunswick. “I told them I was looking right at the cards, and
they definitely exist. The customer wanted to give them back
to me. He just wanted a new deck.”

Guitar put the deck up for bid on eBay. “I checked the
next morning, and it was up to $210. I thought that was
pretty good.” The final bid was $13,100. Guitar split the
money with the original customer.

The buyer is a man from North Carolina, who, Guitar
said, isn’t even a Magic player or collector. He told me he
just wanted something unique to give to his granddaughter.
At press time, the check from the buyer was in the pos-
session of Guitar and attorneys on both sides were verifying
the legitimacy of the check and the cards, but Guitar was
confident the transaction would go through.

This is not the first time such a printing error has
occurred. In 1994, several Magic cards from the Fallen
Empires set were printed with card backs from the
Wyvern CCG.

The moral of the story? (Implying there’s only one.) The collecting community is real, and it goes far beyond the silent majority that favors the Reserved List. There’s a market for whatever you’re selling – no matter how bad, crazy, ugly, or useless it seems. And there’s not only one thing about Magic that people enjoy.


Uncharted Realms

Considering how free Wizards of the Coast has been recently about cutting story-related things and throwing around rhetorical questions like “If people liked Coldsnap, why didn’t they buy more of it?”, I would suggest that anyone who likes the Magic storylines and worldbuilding head over to the main site now and look at the new Uncharted Realms column. If you believe what they say, they keep track of how many hits each of their regular column gets (and how long people spend on the page, so be careful with that) and decide what to promote and what to cut accordingly.

There’s still way too many Spike-oriented deck tweaking articles on there for my liking (and I count Adam Styborski in that number), but one thing at a time.

The beaten path

“There is no book or teacher to give you the answers, to show you the path. Choose your own way.”

— Ezio Auditore, in Assassin’s Creed II

So, you guys remember the time I confessed my affection for repacks, right? Well, I was on Black Ninja’s website, as I sometimes am, and I saw . . . well, probably you can guess what I’m about to say, if you followed that link. If you just run the numbers, do the ratio, 4,000 Magic cards for $97 is a ridiculous deal. I’d probably take it right now if I were closer to done sorting my current collection.

There is, as we know, a love-hate relationship with repacks among Magic players. Some people use them to start their collection, but then “graduate” to buying single cards for their decks from retailers. Others ignore them altogether, deriding them for the characteristic lack of power cards (the last large set I bought had not a single copy of Incinerate, an old, often-reissued, and iconic red card); and if they buy unsorted sets at all, it’s only from new sets (ZOMFG Standard!!1). Still others presumably buy them frequently – these people are not represented in the online community, but their existence can be inferred from the fact that so many online retailers offer repacks, and many different kinds of them too.

If that last statement is a surprise to you, try to consider it from such a buyer’s point of view. Someone who had a playgroup that wasn’t interested in tournaments or Standard in general could find this very appealing. To someone who started recently but is interested in Magic’s history, a 4,000 card Black Ninja repack is rather like the TCG equivalent of one of those “Sounds of the 60s” compilation albums. Or maybe – and in this age of economic collapse, I suspect this is more common than any of us think – they’ve had the experience of looking up a card in the Standard section of a site like Troll and Toad, multiplying the price by four, and coming up with a number well over $100. Maybe they’ve gone to buy a “junk” rare after it was mentioned in a casual-play article on a popular website like or Star City Games, only to find that its price has doubled over the weekend because 15,000 people read the same article they did.

Money is more like time than it is like any commodity or resource: if you enjoyed the result, spending it wasn’t a waste. Which are you likely to enjoy more: four cards that have a “use-by date” in the eyes of the so-called community, or 4,000 cards that, in effect, last for ever?

Hello world!

Hello world indeed.

Since May 2008, I’ve been blogging about Magic: the Gathering from the casual/collector point of view at Recently it’s come to my attention that it was time for a new site and a new host – so here we are. If you’re an existing follower, you probably know what to expect, but it’ll be in much nicer surroundings this time. If you’re reading this site for the first time, it’s going to be a wild ride.